Crowdfunding Lawyers

Convertible Notes Explained: The Smart Investor’s Guide to Understanding and Using Convertible Notes

February 3, 2024
Convertible Notes Explained: The Smart Investor’s Guide to Understanding and Using Convertible Notes

Imagine the rise of a small start-up, blossoming into a tech giant valued at millions. Now, imagine that journey was fueled not by traditional equity investments, but by convertible notes. This, dear reader, is not a mere fantasy. Companies like Airbnb have successfully navigated this path, leveraging the power and flexibility of convertible notes to hasten their ascent to the top.

But what exactly is a convertible note? Picture it as a loan, but with a twist. Instead of simply being repaid, it can metamorphosis into an equity stake in the company. It’s a hybrid investment instrument, used primarily by early-stage start-ups to raise capital without setting a firm valuation. Now, let’s delve deeper into this intriguing financial instrument.

Key Takeaways

  • Convertible notes provide speed, cost-efficiency, and adaptability compared to a priced round of financing but require careful consideration.
  • They offer quick and easy funding with the potential for higher returns, discounts, valuation caps, and conversion triggers.
  • Risks include dilution & changes in control as well as default/insolvency risks – legal considerations & regulatory compliance are essential when issuing or investing in convertible notes.

What Are Convertible Notes?

Often referred to as convertible debt, convertible notes are distinct financial tools capable of transforming into equity. They usually take two forms: Simple Agreements for Future Equity (SAFEs) and convertible notes. These instruments offer several benefits, including speed, cost-efficiency, and adaptability, compared to a priced round of financing, which requires a pre-money valuation.

However, like any financial instrument, convertible notes carry their own set of considerations. Founders need to be mindful of factors like the valuation cap, conversion discount, and conversion triggers. Each of these terms has a significant impact on the potential benefits and risks linked with convertible notes.

The Basics of Convertible Notes

At its core, a convertible note is a debt instrument that blends features of debt and equity investments, often referred to as convertible note debt. This fusion provides versatility for all parties involved. For startups, convertible notes provide a swift and efficient fundraising method, eliminating the immediate need to set a valuation or agree on a share price during the investment phase. For investors, it presents a less risky proposition, with potential rewards if the company succeeds.

Convertible notes are initially recorded as debt on a company’s balance sheet. This continues until a conversion event takes place that leads to the notes being converted into another form of security. This event could be a subsequent financing round or a specific milestone achievement, at which point the notes are converted into equity. The conversion takes into account a valuation cap and a conversion discount, protecting early investors.

How Convertible Notes Work

The appeal of convertible notes stems from their flexible and adaptable nature. Essentially, they start as debt instruments, complete with interest rates and maturity dates. However, they possess the potential to morph into equity upon the occurrence of certain events, such as a subsequent financing round. This unique mechanism allows startups to raise funds quickly without the need for exhaustive negotiations overvaluations and stockholder rights.

The conversion of notes into equity typically happens upon an agreed-upon conversion event, such as a future fundraising round or liquidation event. The price at which the convertible note will convert to equity is determined by either a valuation cap or a discount rate. However, not every priced equity round necessitates a conversion for convertible notes. They may possess extra criteria concerning what constitutes a priced equity round that necessitates conversion, for example, a specified minimum amount raised in the priced round.

Benefits of Using Convertible Notes

One could aptly describe convertible notes as a financial shortcut. Convertible notes offer:

  • Quick and easy funding without the need for comprehensive valuation processes
  • Flexibility in terms of how much equity the startup will eventually give up
  • Speed and convenience in the financing process

For early investors, convertible notes offer several advantages compared to conventional equity investments. These advantages include:

  • Discount rate on conversion
  • Valuation cap
  • Simpler and faster execution process
  • Lower risks
  • Potential for higher returns

Convertible notes can be a verifiable goldmine for investors.

For Startups

Convertible notes serve as a simplifying tool for startups in the complicated realm of fundraising. By issuing convertible notes to investors in exchange for funding, startups can:

  • Secure capital without having to set a valuation at the time of investment
  • Acquire funding swiftly
  • Postpone the valuation negotiation until a later stage

Convertible notes offer startups:

  • A way to raise capital without sacrificing equity control and ownership during their initial growth stages
  • The ability to focus on developing their product and proving their value prior to determining the price of their equity
  • Streamlined negotiation process, allowing startups to quickly secure funding and hit the ground running

For Investors

Convertible notes offer substantial benefits to investors. By offering the potential for a higher return on investment if the startup succeeds, convertible notes are a favorite among early-stage convertible notes investors such as angel investors and venture capitalists.

One of the prime perks for investors is the chance to purchase shares at a lower price than that offered to new investors in a qualified financing round when the convertible note converts into equity. This discount provides a benefit to the investor by allowing them to acquire more shares for their investment. Moreover, convertible note investors are generally prioritized in the event of a company’s bankruptcy, providing an additional layer of security.

Key Terms and Conditions in Convertible Notes

Like all financial instruments, convertible notes have their own specific terms and conditions that make the convertible note work. These terms often encompass valuation caps, conversion discounts, and conversion triggers, each significantly influencing the potential benefits and risks tied to convertible notes.

Each of these terms serves a specific purpose:

  • The valuation cap establishes a maximum valuation at which the note can convert into equity.
  • The conversion discount is an incentive offered to investors when the note converts from debt to equity.
  • Conversion triggers refer to events or conditions that result in the conversion of the convertible notes into equity or repayment.

Valuation Cap

The valuation cap serves as both a valuation cap and a form of safety net for investors. It sets a maximum company valuation at conversion, thus allowing investors to convert their notes at a lower price should the company’s valuation exceed the cap. This protects the investor by ensuring that they receive a predetermined percentage of the company’s equity, regardless of any potential increase in the company’s valuation prior to the conversion.

The valuation cap essentially calculates the conversion price by dividing the capped valuation by the number of shares outstanding. It serves to set a maximum company valuation at conversion, thus allowing investors to convert their notes at a lower price should the company’s valuation exceed the cap. It assures the investors to get a minimum equity stake in the company regardless of how much the company’s valuation increases.

Conversion Discount

The conversion discount is a reward for early investors. It offers them a reduced price for equity conversion, thus providing them with a reward for their early support. It acts as a loyalty bonus, acknowledging the company’s early supporters.

The conversion discount rate, which can be influenced by the prevailing interest rate, is typically a reduced price, usually ranging from 10% to 35% lower than the price paid by new investors in the qualified round. This discount rate is applied when the interest rate convertible notes convert into equity. For instance, if the market rate is $2.50 per share and the convertible note has a 20% discount, the investor can purchase shares for $2.00.

Conversion Triggers

Convertible note’s conversion triggers function similarly to milestones on a journey. They refer to events that prompt the conversion of convertible notes into equity, such as:

  • a financing round
  • an initial public offering (IPO)
  • achieving a specified level of funding
  • a change of control
  • meeting certain share price performance criteria

When a conversion trigger event occurs in convertible notes, it implies that the notes will be converted into shares or be subject to repayment. This provides investors with the potential to benefit from the rise in the company’s value.

Comparing Convertible Notes with Other Financing Instruments

Though unique, convertible notes are merely one of the myriad financial tools accessible to startups and investors. They share the stage with other instruments like Simple Agreements for Future Equity (SAFEs) and senior convertible notes. Each of these instruments has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, and the choice between them often boils down to the specific needs and circumstances of the startup and its investors.

It’s akin to selecting from various transport options for a trip. While a convertible note may be akin to a speedy car that gets you quickly to your destination, a SAFE might be more like a bicycle, slower but without the pressure of interest rates and maturity dates. On the other hand, senior convertible notes may offer the comfort and security of a train, with priority repayment and conversion rights over other debt securities. Let’s delve into these comparisons further.

SAFEs vs. Convertible Notes

SAFEs and convertible notes are two elements of the same entity. Both are financial instruments that convert into equity, but they have key differences. SAFEs, in particular, lack interest rates and maturity dates, making them a preferred choice for founders seeking to avoid debt obligations.

While convertible notes are more like loans that accrue interest and have a maturity date, SAFEs are simpler and quicker to execute. The absence of interest rates and maturity dates can make SAFEs more attractive to founders, especially those who wish to avoid accruing debt.

SAFEs are similar to convertible notes. In a future equity financing round, they both convert into equity.

Senior Convertible Notes

Senior convertible notes can be compared to a first-class ticket in the fundraising process. They offer priority repayment and conversion rights over other debt securities, making them less risky for investors. However, the trade-off is that they can potentially be more dilutive for founders.

These notes offer a lower risk of default compared to other debt instruments due to the option to convert into equity. However, they do carry some risks, including dilution of ownership, uncertainty of conversion, and limited control. Despite the risks, debt investment in the form of these notes can be an attractive option for startups due to their lower interest obligations and simplicity compared to other debt offerings.

Potential Risks and Drawbacks of Convertible Notes

While convertible notes are a unique and effective financing tool, they are not without their risks and drawbacks. The potential for dilution of founder ownership, changes in control and voting rights, and risks of default and insolvency are all factors that must be considered when using convertible notes.

In the context of convertible notes, advantages often come with disadvantages. The conversion of these notes into equity can result in a reduction of the ownership percentage of existing shareholders, a phenomenon known as dilution. This can impact the ownership structure and decision-making power within the company. Furthermore, if the company fails to raise additional funding or goes bankrupt, investors may face losses.

Dilution and Control Changes

Two major risks tied to convertible notes are dilution and changes in control. Dilution refers to the reduction in the ownership percentage of existing shareholders when a company issues additional shares. This can occur when a company closes a funding round or expands its employee stock option pool.

These changes to control and voting rights can impact the dynamics of a startup. Convertible note holders may gain voting rights on certain matters, such as electing the board of directors or approving major corporate decisions. This can dilute the control and voting rights of existing shareholders, potentially disrupting the balance of power within the company.

Default and Insolvency Risks

Default and insolvency risks are inherent in any debt instrument, and convertible notes are no exception. If a company defaults on a convertible note or becomes insolvent, investors may face significant losses.

In the event of bankruptcy, the holder of a convertible note may receive nothing or only a portion of the amount invested. The convertible note may be treated as a debt obligation and paid from the bankruptcy proceeds, but the amount received is usually minimal. To mitigate these risks, investors should undertake comprehensive due diligence, diversify their investments, and seek professional legal advice.

Legal Considerations and Best Practices

Understanding the legal intricacies of convertible notes can be challenging. But adhering to regulatory compliance and seeking expert legal advice can make the journey smoother.

Convertible notes fall under the regulations laid down by the Securities Act, which includes registration or eligibility for an exemption. Failure to adhere to these regulations can result in penalties and legal consequences. Therefore, startups and investors may want to seek legal counsel from Crowdfunding Lawyers to ensure they are compliant with these regulations when issuing or investing in convertible notes.

Regulatory Compliance

Ensuring regulatory compliance is an essential part of issuing convertible notes. It refers to the practice of adhering to laws and regulations to ensure operations are conducted in accordance with established standards. Non-compliance can lead to legal and financial consequences.

Convertible notes must adhere to the filing requirements of the Exchange Act. The terms of the investment are delineated in convertible promissory notes, which may include provisions for conversion into equity. Compliance with these regulations is paramount to avoid penalties and maintain the integrity of the investment.

Seeking Expert Advice

Seeking expert advice proves extremely beneficial in matters related to convertible notes. A financial advisor can provide experienced counsel and help manage a portfolio that includes convertible bonds. Additionally, Crowdfunding Lawyers’ team can guide startups and investors through the process, ensuring informed decisions are made.

From structuring the terms of convertible notes to conducting a comprehensive analysis of the investment opportunity, expert advice can provide valuable insights. By leveraging working with us, investors can mitigate risks, maximize their returns, and make well-informed investment decisions when considering convertible notes.

Convertible Notes: Final Thoughts

Convertible notes are a versatile and useful tool for both investors and startups. They offer unique benefits such as flexibility, simplicity, and protection for both parties involved. As a smart investor, it is important to understand these notes so that you can make informed decisions and maximize your returns. 

We hope this guide has shed some light on the intricacies of convertible notes and provided valuable insights for your investment journey. However, it is crucial to remember that every situation is unique, and seeking professional advice from experts like the team at Crowdfunding Lawyers can help ensure compliance and safeguard your investments. With our experience and knowledge in the field of crowdfunding, we can assist you in navigating through any complexities that may arise with convertible notes. 

Don’t hesitate to reach out to us today and take control of your investments with confidence! Remember – knowledge is power, but having the right team on your side can help you turn that power into success.

Similar articles

Regulations: Understanding Regulations D, CF, A, and S
Regulations: Understanding Regulations D, CF, A, and S
Richard Robinette
Structuring an investment correctly is essential. If you fail to do so, you run afoul of the SEC and...
January 18, 2023
Specific Questions and Answers Regarding Reg D, Rule 506 B
Specific Questions and Answers Regarding Reg D, Rule 506 B
Nathaniel Dodson
Is it possible to create a Facebook group on real estate investing and then proceed to execute an ...
December 14, 2021
Understanding the Manager’s Role in an LLC
Understanding the Manager’s Role in an LLC
Nathaniel Dodson
Each business formation has specific strengths and weaknesses. They also have their own structures. ...
July 28, 2023